| Date | Location | Result | |
| Sep 15, 2012 | Latrobe, PA | Waynesburg 35, Saint Vincent 14 | Box score |
| Sep 15, 2012 | Greenville, Pa. | Thiel 21, Geneva 14 | Box score |
| Sep 15, 2012 | Washington, Pa. | Wash. & Jeff. 24, Grove City 17 | Box score |
| Sep 15, 2012 | Ashland, VA | Randolph-Macon 49, Bethany 33 | Box score |
| Sep 15, 2012 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 27, Westminster 23 | Box score |
| Sep 08, 2012 | Washington, Pa. | St. John Fisher 28, Wash. & Jeff. 24 | Box score |
| Sep 08, 2012 | Latrobe, PA | Wooster 27, Saint Vincent 21 | Box score |
| Sep 08, 2012 | Geneva, N.Y. | Hobart 28, Geneva 7 | Box score |
| Sep 08, 2012 | Grove City, Pa. | Grove City 47, Anderson 10 | Box score |
| Sep 08, 2012 | Waynesburg, Pa. | Waynesburg 21, Frostburg State 7 | Box score |
| 9/08/2012 | Rochester, NY | Univ. of Rochester 17, Thiel 7 | Box score |
| Sep 01, 2012 | Frostburg, Md. | Frostburg State 56, Geneva 53 | Box score |
| Sep 01, 2012 | Latrobe, PA | Bridgewater 23, Saint Vincent 7 | Box score |
| Sep 01, 2012 | New Wilmington, Pa. | Westminster 28, Hiram 0 | Box score |
| Sep 01, 2012 | Pittsford, N.Y. | St. John Fisher 13, Thomas More 7 | Box score |
| Sep 01, 2012 | Fayetteville, N.C. | Wash. & Jeff. 23, Methodist 6 | Box score |
| Sep 1, 2012 | Pittsburgh, Pa. | Carnegie Mellon 23, Grove City 20 | Box score |
| Sep 01, 2012 | Bethany, W.Va. | Centre 42, Bethany 21 | Box score |
| Sep 01, 2012 | Muskingum Univesity | Waynesburg 34, Muskingum University 23 | Box score |
| Sep 01, 2012 | Greenville, Pa. | Juniata 16, Thiel 13 | Box score |