| Date | Location | Result | |
| 11/28/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Johns Hopkins 31, Thomas More 29 | Box score |
| 11/21/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 49, DePauw 39 | Box score |
| Nov 21, 2009 | Greenville, Ill. | Geneva 29, Greenville 28 | Box score |
| Nov 20, 2009 | Alliance, OH | Mount Union 55, Wash. & Jeff. 0 | Box score |
| Nov 14, 2009 | New Wilmington, Pa. | Westminster 31, Geneva 28 | Box score |
| 11/14/09 | Cincinnati, Ohio | Thomas More 42, Mount St. Joseph 17 | Box score |
| Nov 14, 2009 | Latrobe, PA | Bethany 34, Saint Vincent 13 | Box score |
| Nov 14, 2009 | Washington, Pa. | Wash. & Jeff. 35, Waynesburg 12 | Box score |
| Nov 14, 2009 | Greenville, Pa. | Grove City 31, Thiel 24 | Box score |
| 11/07/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 21, Geneva 12 | Box score |
| Nov 07, 2009 | Bethany, W.Va. | Wash. & Jeff. 49, Bethany 0 | Box score |
| Nov 07, 2009 | Waynesburg, Pa. | Waynesburg 38, Thiel 17 | Box score |
| Nov 07, 2009 | Grove City, Pa. | Grove City 38, Westminster 31 | Box score |
| Oct 24, 2009 | Beaver Falls, PA | Geneva 38, Saint Vincent 20 | Box score |
| Oct 24, 2009 | New Wilmington, Pa. | Wash. & Jeff. 49, Westminster 7 | Box score |
| Oct 24, 2009 | Waynesburg, Pa. | Waynesburg 52, Bethany 13 | Box score |
| Oct 24, 2009 | Greenville, Pa. | Thomas More 28, Thiel 14 | Box score |
| Oct 17, 2009 | Bethany, W.Va. | Westminster 31, Bethany 28 | Box score |
| 10/17/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 17, Grove City 7 | Box score |
| Oct 17, 2009 | Latrobe, Pa. | Wash. & Jeff. 21, Saint Vincent 7 | Box score |
| Oct 17, 2009 | Waynesburg, Pa. | Geneva 49, Waynesburg 39 | Box score |
| Oct 10, 2009 | New Wilmington, Pa. | Westminster 49, Waynesburg 42 | Box score |
| Oct 10, 2009 | Bethany, W.Va. | Bethany 42, Thiel 21 | Box score |
| Oct 10, 2009 | Latrobe, PA | Thomas More 40, Saint Vincent 13 | Box score |
| Oct 10, 2009 | Beaver Falls, Pa. | Geneva 34, Grove City 17 | Box score |
| 10/03/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 40, Bethany 12 | Box score |
| Oct 3, 2009 | Washington, Pa. | Wash. & Jeff. 31, Geneva 10 | Box score |
| Oct 03, 2009 | Grove City, Pa. | Grove City 41, Saint Vincent 20 | Box score |
| Oct 03, 2009 | Greenville, PA | Thiel 24, Westminster 21 | Box score |
| Sep 26, 2009 | New Wilmington, Pa. | Thomas More 34, Westminster 16 | Box score |
| Sep 26, 2009 | Beaver Falls, PA | Geneva 37, Thiel 13 | Box score |
| Sep 26, 2009 | Grove City, Pa. | Wash. & Jeff. 28, Grove City 10 | Box score |
| Sep 26, 2009 | Waynesburg, Pa. | Waynesburg 33, Saint Vincent 12 | Box score |
| Sep 19, 2009 | Latrobe, PA | Westminster 27, Saint Vincent 14 | Box score |
| 09/19/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 47, Waynesburg 24 | Box score |
| Sep 19, 2009 | Washington, Pa. | Wash. & Jeff. 56, Thiel 16 | Box score |
| Sep 19, 2009 | Bethany, W.Va. | Grove City 35, Bethany 14 | Box score |
| Sep 12, 2009 | Meadville, Pa. | Allegheny 27, Westminster 14 | Box score |
| Sep 12, 2009 | Frostburg, Md. | Wash. & Jeff. 34, Frostburg State 12 | Box score |
| Sep 12, 2009 | South Point, Ohio | Bethany 41, Kentucky Christian 33 | Box score |
| Sep 12, 2009 | Pittsburgh, Pa. | Carnegie Mellon 45, Grove City 40 | Box score |
| Sep 12, 2009 | Waynesburg, Pa. | Waynesburg 49, Hanover 21 | Box score |
| Sep 12, 2009 | Latrobe, PA | Geneva 32, Saint Vincent 17 | Box score |
| Sep 12, 2009 | Greenville, Pa. | Thiel 20, Albion 10 | Box score |
| 09/05/09 | New Wilmington, Pa. | Heidelberg 42, Westminster 26 | Box score |
| 09/05/09 | University Hts, Ohio | Thomas More 14, John Carroll 7 | Box score |
| Sep 05, 2009 | Beaver Falls, PA | Geneva 41, Frostburg State 28 | Box score |
| Sept 5, 2009 | Washington, Pa. | Wash. & Jeff. 35, Oberlin 9 | Box score |
| Sep 05, 2009 | Bethany, W.Va. | Otterbein 28, Bethany 7 | Box score |
| Sep 05, 2009 | Grove City, Pa. | Dickinson 52, Grove City 47 | Box score |
| Sep 05, 2009 | Wooster, Ohio | Waynesburg 42, College of Wooster 39 | Box score |
| Sep 05, 2009 | Westminster, Md. | McDaniel 52, Saint Vincent 37 | Box score |
| Sep 05, 2009 | Marietta, Ohio | Marietta 20, Thiel 14 | Box score |
| Oct 31, 2009 | Beaver Falls, PA | Geneva 54, Bethany 21 | Box score |
| Oct 31, 2009 | Washington, Pa. | Thomas More 14, Wash. & Jeff. 7 | Box score |
| Oct 31, 2009 | Grove City, Pa. | Grove City 35, Waynesburg 24 | Box score |
| Oct 31, 2009 | Greenville, Pa. | Thiel 38, Saint Vincent 14 | Box score |